Research Roundup
December 21, 2009

Tools for the future
The near future
Social trends, etc.
Other articles, essays, and recent items of interest
Refresh and reflect



Tools for the future:
  1. Advice on How to Cut Through Complexity and Get Things Done from BNET. "Complexity is an epidemic. Mass customization, choice overload, and the proliferation of gadgets have conspired to consume our cycles and productivity. And product proliferation, communication congestion, and analysis paralysis have made the workplace chaotic." The same is just as true in the non-profit sector as it is in the business world.  
  2. From the Flowing Data blog, the 5 Best Data Visualization Projects of the Year. As they write, "It was a huge year for data. There's no denying it. Data is about to explode. Applications sprung up left and right that help you understand your data—your Web traffic, your finances, and your life. There are now online marketplaces that sell data as files or via API. Data.gov launched to provide the public with usable, machine-readable data on a national scale. State and local governments followed, and data availability expands every day."


The near future:
  1. The Gaming Insider blog at MediaPost ponders How Games Are Supporting Personalized Narratives: "Online content, as it becomes increasingly interactive and tailored to the individual, faces a problem: How does it deliver an individual experience and still contribute to a cultural identity?" Similar questions are posed in CFM's 2008 trends report (see the section on "myCulture") and the 2008 CFM lecture by Jane McGonigal ("Gaming the Future of Museums"). 
  2. New research based on a survey of 9th-graders suggests that Civic Education Boosts 21st-Century Skills. In a report entitled "Paths to 21st Century Competencies through Civic Education Classrooms," the authors argue that
    Civic education, especially when it is interactive and involves discussion of current issues, is an important way to develop the skills that young Americans need to succeed in the 21st Century workforce. Students who experience interactive discussion-based civic education (either by itself or in combination with lecture-based civic education) score the highest on '21st Century Competencies,' including working with others (especially in diverse groups) and knowledge of economic and political processes. Students who experience neither interactive nor lecture-based civic education have the lowest scores on all of the 21st Century competencies examined. This group, which comprises about one-quarter of all American students, shows not only low levels of knowledge but also a relatively low level of willingness to obey the law.
    The report does not mention an explicit role for museums and other informal learning environments. (From CIRCLE, the Center for Information and Research on Civic Learning and Engagement at Tufts University.)
  3. From the Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission comes Connections: The Regional Plan for a Sustainable Future—an especially thoughtful model for sustainable regional development. The plan is built around four key principles: Create Livable Communities; Manage Growth and Protect Resources; Build an Energy-Efficient Economy; and Establish a Modern, Multimodal Transportation System. The important role of museums in long-term planning is mentioned at several points. (Via Issue Lab.) 


Social trends, etc.:
  1. This month the National Endowment for the Arts released detailed results from the latest Survey of Public Participation in the Arts. These are contained in a long Research Report and brief Research Note from the agency. Also, the NEA convened a meeting with arts service organizations on Dec. 10 to discuss the results; the webcast is archived on the Research section of the NEA website (http://www.nea.gov/research/index.html). Finally, for researchers who want to dig even deeper into the data, see http://www.nea.gov/research/SPPA/index.html.  
  2. The NEA data point to a long-term decline in the percentage of American adults who visit art museums. But according to The Art Newspaper, Museum attendance rises as the economy tumbles (at least in 2009). This is based on an unscientific survey of 20 leading art museums—but it supports other anecdotal evidence for a rise in attendance at all sorts of museums during the past year. More rigorous research is required to confirm this.
  3. In one artist's response to the challenge of climate sustainability, Maya Lin unveiled a new video work at the UN summit on climate change in Copenhagen, Unchopping a Tree. The video is part of her latest memorial, a multi-sited, multi-medium piece called "What is Missing"; inspired by a W.S. Merwin poem, the video focuses on how we would feel if deforestation came to the city parks that we love the most. (Via Fast Company.)
  4. Mint.com, a website devoted to personal finance, asks Charity: Who Cares? But the question is meant to be ironic, because clearly they do care: "Americans lead the world in charitable contributions, giving $300 billion a year to charities. Sounds like a lot right? But this is just a drop in the bucket compared to the over One Trillion Dollars needed to keep US charities in operation, more than the US government collects in taxes. The rest comes from their own assets, government support, and foreign investment. Our visual guide to giving shows who's paying and offers some tips on how to pick a charity of your own."
  5. Forbes.com, a website devoted to big finance, has a list of America's 200 Largest Charities (by value of donations). "For the first time since we began tracking these giants in 1999, they collectively lost money. For our reckoning last year, they ran surpluses (from operations and investment returns) averaging $66 million. This year: a $6 million loss. The blame goes primarily to severe investment losses, coupled in some cases with new accounting rules requiring financial statement charges for employee pensions." By our count, 10 of the giants are museums, but they are clustered in the bottom half of the list.
  6. Two on the arts and learning:
  • In November, the Dana Foundation published Neuroeducation: Learning, Arts, and the Brain, drawn from a May 2009 conference on the intersection of cognitive neuroscience, the arts, and learning (including the effects of early arts education on other aspects of cognition and the implications for policy and practice). (Via the Foundation Center's PubHub.)
  • A few weeks earlier, the College Board's National Task Force on the Arts in Education released Arts at the Core: Recommendations for Advancing the State of Arts Education in the 21st Century. One recommendation is to "promote alliances with global artists"—i.e., "professional artists or highly skilled hobbyists who maintain a particular global artistic tradition. They are found in local communities in ethnic restaurants, folk and art centers, museums, playhouses, churches, synagogues and mosques."


Other articles, essays, and recent items of interest:
  1. Jordan Jacobs, "Repatriation and the Reconstruction of Identity," Museum Anthropology 32:2 (October 2009). Available via Policy Archive at https://www.policyarchive.org/handle/10207/14865. Here is the abstract:
    A proposed change to American repatriation law provides an opportunity to reexamine the assumptions on which the original statute was built. For their justification, NAGPRA and the NMAI Act rely on the supposition that bounded communities proceed through time along a unilinear path—a misconception stemming from both universal, identity-forming processes and the discipline of archaeology itself. A case study involving the National Museum of the American Indian's 2003 repatriation of human remains to a rural village in Cuba demonstrates how various identities can manipulate the transfer of archaeological material to fit their own symbolic needs.
  2. Why Buy Local is an infographic from Local First, a Grand Rapids, Michigan based organization that encourages sustainable, locally-based economies. Includes ten reasons why spending money locally (say, at the local museum) benefits the local community. (Via the PSFK website.) 
  3. Design Indaba, a South African design firm/social innovation think-tank, is speculating about the future of farming through a project entitled Protofarm 2050. This is not your father's or grandmother's farm -- even though they advocate small and mid-sized farms as the path to sustainability, the new context is "increased [global] urbanisation and population, limited natural resources, climate challenges and digital-biological integration." (See more on the project at the PSFK website.)


Refresh and reflect:
  1. The Biblical Archaeology Review explains How December 25 Became Christmas .
  2. Wait for the Death Bear, who can visit your home on January 10-11 (if you live in Brooklyn, at least) and "take things from you that trigger painful memories and stow them away in his cave where they will remain forever allowing you to move on with your life."